EMD's NW3 and NW5 Versatile Switchers

Ex-Great Northern NW3 #181 welcomes visitors to Whitefish Montana

Introduced late in 1946 by Electro-Motive Division of GM; it has been suggested that the NW5, given its 1000 horsepower and Bloomberg road trucks was in response to Alco's successful RS1 -- that's not the case at all. The model was an effort by the locomotive builder to improve on the very weak-selling 900-hp NW3 model that had entered the marketplace in 1939 -- two years prior to Alco's RS1.

Although both EMD models were geared for 65-mph running and showcased a steam generator, which afforded railroads greater flexibility, they barely moved the needle on the sales chart. With its offset cab and short forward hood, the NW5 models presented a distinctive profile. However, total production of the two light-weight road-switcher only netted 20 units, 13 of which were the larger-horsepower copy.

In a era of burgeoning passenger train numbers, Great Northern was the only class one railroad that attempted to capitalize on the potential merits of the NW3 / NW5; GN purchased seven NW3s and ten NW5s. Southern Railway had a token purchase that saw one NW5 added to its roster. The only other buyer was the Fort Street Union Depot in Detroit (aka Union Belt of Detroit) which signed a deal for two NW5s. Infrequently did any of these elongated units wander beyond their conventional passenger coach yard duties.

Interestingly, a few of these rare EMDs worked beyond the 1990s; three of which can be now seen at railroad museums, and one on displayed in Montana along the old "EMpire Builder" route.

Original Buyers

NW3 From this perspective, it is easy to understand why a railroad would perceive the NW3 as a terminal switcher rather than a light road-switcher. The bulge in front of the cab was a stesm generator-housing. (Jim Herold photo at Whitefish, MT in October 1991 / Vince Porreca collection )

NW5 You don't necessarily have to be a Great Northern fan to appreciate the aesthetic value of the railroad's "Empire Builder" livery. The NW5's short hood housed a steam generator. (Vince Porreca photo at xxxxxxx, xxx in xxxxx 19xx )
blank

NW5 Delivered during January and February 1947, the #1 and #2 spent 17 years assembling long-distance trains for each of the four class one railroads that utilized Fort Street Union Depot in Detroit. Tthe NW5 pair were sold afterwards to separate owners. (J. David Ingles photo in 1959)

NW5 Southern #2100 spent several years working the New Orleans passenger terminal. Interestingly, a review of different Southern period photos indicate that the steam generator had been removed long before its sales to private industry. (George Gorna photo in July 1972)

Second-Hand NW3 Owners

Clinchfield RR #361 (ex-GN 5405 / 180) --- Warren Calloway photo

A.E. Staley (ex-GN #179 < nee #5404) at Morrisville, PA in May 1979. --- Vince Porreca photo)

Second-Hand NW5 Owners

Burlington Northern #988 (ex-GN #188) at Spokane, Washington in July 1970 --- Vince Porreca photo

Colorado & Eastern #986 (ex-GN #186) at Denver, Colorado in September 1993 --- Vince Porreca photo

Council Bluffs Railway #992 (ex-GN #192) at Council Bluffs, Iowa in September 1993 --- Vince Porreca photo

Gardinier Phosphate #61 (ex-FSUD #2) at Tampa, Florida in August 1978 --- a Bill Folsom photo photo

Great Western #994 (ex-GN 194) at Loveland, Colorado in November 1983 --- Alan M. Miller photo

Mass Central #2100 (ex-Southern Rwy 2100) at Palmer, Massachusetts on 27 June 2008 --- T. Davis photo

Mississippi Export #61 (ex-FSUD #2) at Moss Point, Mississippi in August 1970 --- Joe Brockmeyer photo

Olin Mathieson Chemical #4 (ex-FSUD #1) at Saltville, Virginia in April 1971 --- Joe Brockmeyer photo

Southern Rails Inc. #61 (ex-FSUD #2) leased to US Phosphoric Products in East Tampa, Florida during 1974 --- Stan Jackowski photo
Text and photos by R. Craig Rutherford


EMD NW3 Roster

Model: NW3
Railroad Road No. BLDr No. Date Other Owners
Great Northern 5400 / 175 869 11/1939 To EMD as trade-in Fodder
5401 / 176 870 11/1939 To EMD as trade-in Fodder
5402 / 177 890 9/1940 To EMD as trade-in Fodder
5403 / 178 8891 4/1941 To EMD as trade-in Fodder
5404 / 179 892 12/1941
  • To AE Staley #179 in 1968
  • Tate & Lyle, America #179 in ??
  • 5405 / 180 1719 3/1942
  • To Clinchfield #361 in ??
  • Scrapped
  • 5406 / 181 1720 3/1942
  • To Anaconda Aluminum #100 in 1965
  • Cosmetically restored and displayed as GN 181 at Whitefish (Station), Montana
  • EMD NW5 Roster

    Railroad Road No. BLDr No. Date Other Owners
    Fort Street Union Depot 1 4148 1/1947
  • To Olin Mathison Chemical 4
  • OM removed steam generator and chopped short hood
  • 2 4149 2/1947
  • To Mississippi Export 2
  • To Florida Gulf RR Museum
  • Great Northern 186 3479 12/1946
  • To BN #986 merger in March 1970
  • To Colorado & Eastern #986 in July 1982
  • To Denver Terminal #986 in February 1987
  • Scrapped c.1996
  • 187 3480 12/1946
  • To BN #987 merger in March 1970
  • To Pacific Trans. #1001 in July 1982
  • To Molalla Western #187 in 1993
  • To Oregon Pacific #986 in 1997
  • 188 3481 12/1946
  • To BN #988 merger in March 1970
  • To scrap
  • 189 3482 12/1946
  • To BN #989 merger in March 1970
  • Wrecked in May 1978
  • 190 3483 12/1946
  • To BN #990 merger in March 1970
  • To Colorado & Eastern #980 in July 1982
  • 191 3484 12/1946
  • To BN #991 merger in March 1970
  • To scrap
  • 192 3485 12/1946
  • To BN #992 merger in March 1970
  • To Colorado & Eastern #992 in July 1982
  • To Lake Superior RR Museum in ?? (active)
  • 193 3486 12/1946
  • To BN #993 merger in March 1970
  • To Precision National Corp. in May 1982
  • 194 3487 12/1946
  • To BN #994 merger in March 1970
  • To Colorado & Eastern #992 in July 1982
  • 195 3488 12/1946
  • To BN #995 merger in March 1970
  • To Precision National Corp. in May 1982
  • Southern Railroad 2100 3615 1/1947
  • To Mass Central #2100 in ??
  • Sources:
    • Burlington Northern 1970 Annual (by Hol Wagner)
    • Flickr.com
    • RR Pictures Archives.com
    • TDS rosters
    • TrainWeb.com

    Disposition data from "Great Northern Empire" website


    Back to Motive Power Rosters

    Back to Shortlines

    New: 1 December 2024